Sirach 20:4 - As is the lust of an eunuch to deflower a virgin; So is he that executes judgements with violence.
Select Bible Verse
Filter Categories
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
R
S
T
U
V
W
What does "Sirach 20:4" mean?
This verse from Sirach (Ecclesiasticus) 20:4 uses a striking and somewhat shocking metaphor to illustrate the futility and perversion of justice when it's carried out with excessive force or without proper authority. Let's break it down:
"As is the lust of an eunuch to deflower a virgin..." An eunuch, by definition, is a man who has been castrated. Therefore, he lacks the physical capacity to consummate the act of "deflowering" a virgin. The "lust" represents desire or a pretense of desire, and the "deflowering" is the act of sexual intimacy. The key point is the futility and inappropriateness of the eunuch's desire. He can want it, he can even pretend to do it, but he can never truly accomplish it. It's a desire that can never be fulfilled and is inherently unnatural. It highlights an emptiness, an inability, and ultimately a perversion of a natural act.
"...So is he that executes judgements with violence." This part connects the metaphor to the actual subject matter: justice and the administration of it. "Executes judgements with violence" refers to someone who carries out justice in an excessive, brutal, or unjust manner, or someone who enforces judgments without proper authority.
The Meaning
The verse is essentially saying that administering justice with unnecessary force, cruelty, or without the proper authority is as pointless and distorted as an eunuch trying to deflower a virgin.
Here's what the comparison suggests:
1. Ineffectiveness: Just as the eunuch's actions are futile, so too is the violent or unjust execution of judgment. It might appear to be effective on the surface, but it doesn't achieve true justice or restoration. It might even cause more harm than good.
2. Inappropriateness/Perversion: The eunuch's desire is considered unnatural and inappropriate. Similarly, executing judgments with violence is a perversion of justice. Justice should be tempered with mercy, fairness, and due process. Violence and cruelty distort the true purpose of justice.
3. Lack of Fulfillment: The eunuch's desire is unfulfillable. Likewise, violent or unjust judgments leave a void, a sense of incompleteness, and a lack of true resolution. It doesn't bring about true healing or reconciliation.
In essence, the verse warns against the abuse of power in the name of justice. It emphasizes that true justice must be rooted in fairness, compassion, and due process, not in brutality or excessive force. When justice is carried out with violence, it becomes a hollow and ultimately futile act, devoid of its true purpose.
Sirach 20:4 - As is the lust of an eunuch to deflower a virgin; So is he that executes judgements with violence.
What does "Sirach 20:4" mean?
This verse from Sirach (Ecclesiasticus) 20:4 uses a striking and somewhat shocking metaphor to illustrate the futility and perversion of justice when it's carried out with excessive force or without proper authority. Let's break it down:
"As is the lust of an eunuch to deflower a virgin..." An eunuch, by definition, is a man who has been castrated. Therefore, he lacks the physical capacity to consummate the act of "deflowering" a virgin. The "lust" represents desire or a pretense of desire, and the "deflowering" is the act of sexual intimacy. The key point is the futility and inappropriateness of the eunuch's desire. He can want it, he can even pretend to do it, but he can never truly accomplish it. It's a desire that can never be fulfilled and is inherently unnatural. It highlights an emptiness, an inability, and ultimately a perversion of a natural act.
"...So is he that executes judgements with violence." This part connects the metaphor to the actual subject matter: justice and the administration of it. "Executes judgements with violence" refers to someone who carries out justice in an excessive, brutal, or unjust manner, or someone who enforces judgments without proper authority.
The Meaning
The verse is essentially saying that administering justice with unnecessary force, cruelty, or without the proper authority is as pointless and distorted as an eunuch trying to deflower a virgin.
Here's what the comparison suggests:
1. Ineffectiveness: Just as the eunuch's actions are futile, so too is the violent or unjust execution of judgment. It might appear to be effective on the surface, but it doesn't achieve true justice or restoration. It might even cause more harm than good.
2. Inappropriateness/Perversion: The eunuch's desire is considered unnatural and inappropriate. Similarly, executing judgments with violence is a perversion of justice. Justice should be tempered with mercy, fairness, and due process. Violence and cruelty distort the true purpose of justice.
3. Lack of Fulfillment: The eunuch's desire is unfulfillable. Likewise, violent or unjust judgments leave a void, a sense of incompleteness, and a lack of true resolution. It doesn't bring about true healing or reconciliation.
In essence, the verse warns against the abuse of power in the name of justice. It emphasizes that true justice must be rooted in fairness, compassion, and due process, not in brutality or excessive force. When justice is carried out with violence, it becomes a hollow and ultimately futile act, devoid of its true purpose.