Matthew 27:23 - But the governor said, “Why? What evil has he done?” But they cried out exceedingly, saying, “Let him be crucified!”
Select Bible Verse
Filter Categories
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
R
S
T
U
V
W
What does "Matthew 27:23" mean?
This verse from Matthew 27:23 is a pivotal moment in the Passion narrative, illustrating the injustice and political maneuvering surrounding Jesus' crucifixion. Let's break down its meaning:
"But the governor said, 'Why? What evil has he done?'" This refers to Pontius Pilate, the Roman governor of Judea. Pilate is presented as reluctant to condemn Jesus. He seems to recognize Jesus' innocence. He's asking for a legitimate reason, a crime Jesus has committed, that warrants the death penalty. This question highlights the lack of any real legal basis for the accusations against Jesus.
"But they cried out exceedingly, saying, 'Let him be crucified!'" "They" refers to the crowd, instigated by the chief priests and elders. Instead of providing a reasoned response to Pilate's question, they simply repeat their demand for Jesus' crucifixion, and they do so with intense fervor ("exceedingly"). This shows the power of mob mentality and the influence of the religious leaders in manipulating the crowd's emotions. "Crucify him" was a particularly brutal and shameful form of Roman punishment, typically reserved for criminals and rebels against the state. The choice of this specific form of execution indicates not only a desire for Jesus' death but also a desire to publicly humiliate him.
Overall Meaning and Significance:
Injustice and Mob Rule: The verse dramatically portrays the injustice of Jesus' trial. Pilate acknowledges Jesus' apparent innocence, but the crowd's relentless and irrational demand for crucifixion overrides any sense of justice. It demonstrates how political pressure and mob mentality can lead to wrongful condemnation.
Pilate's Weakness: While Pilate acknowledges Jesus' lack of guilt, he ultimately gives in to the pressure of the crowd. This highlights his moral weakness and his prioritization of political expediency over doing what is right. He fears a potential riot or rebellion if he defies the crowd, which could jeopardize his position with Rome.
Theological Implications: From a Christian perspective, this verse contributes to the understanding of Jesus' sacrifice. His willingness to endure suffering and death, even when innocent, is seen as an act of love and redemption for humanity. It underscores the idea that Jesus was unjustly condemned and died for the sins of the world.
Antisemitism (Important Caution): Throughout history, this passage and similar accounts in the Gospels have been misused to justify antisemitism. It's crucial to understand that the "they" in this verse refers to a specific crowd in Jerusalem at that time, incited by particular religious leaders. It does not represent the entire Jewish people, either then or now. Blaming all Jews for the death of Jesus is a dangerous and harmful misinterpretation of the text.
In conclusion, Matthew 27:23 is a powerful verse that reveals the injustice of Jesus' trial, the manipulation of the crowd, Pilate's moral weakness, and the theological significance of Jesus' sacrifice. It also serves as a warning against the dangers of mob rule and the importance of upholding justice, and it should be interpreted with careful attention to avoid harmful antisemitic interpretations.
Matthew 27:23 - But the governor said, “Why? What evil has he done?” But they cried out exceedingly, saying, “Let him be crucified!”
What does "Matthew 27:23" mean?
This verse from Matthew 27:23 is a pivotal moment in the Passion narrative, illustrating the injustice and political maneuvering surrounding Jesus' crucifixion. Let's break down its meaning:
"But the governor said, 'Why? What evil has he done?'" This refers to Pontius Pilate, the Roman governor of Judea. Pilate is presented as reluctant to condemn Jesus. He seems to recognize Jesus' innocence. He's asking for a legitimate reason, a crime Jesus has committed, that warrants the death penalty. This question highlights the lack of any real legal basis for the accusations against Jesus.
"But they cried out exceedingly, saying, 'Let him be crucified!'" "They" refers to the crowd, instigated by the chief priests and elders. Instead of providing a reasoned response to Pilate's question, they simply repeat their demand for Jesus' crucifixion, and they do so with intense fervor ("exceedingly"). This shows the power of mob mentality and the influence of the religious leaders in manipulating the crowd's emotions. "Crucify him" was a particularly brutal and shameful form of Roman punishment, typically reserved for criminals and rebels against the state. The choice of this specific form of execution indicates not only a desire for Jesus' death but also a desire to publicly humiliate him.
Overall Meaning and Significance:
Injustice and Mob Rule: The verse dramatically portrays the injustice of Jesus' trial. Pilate acknowledges Jesus' apparent innocence, but the crowd's relentless and irrational demand for crucifixion overrides any sense of justice. It demonstrates how political pressure and mob mentality can lead to wrongful condemnation.
Pilate's Weakness: While Pilate acknowledges Jesus' lack of guilt, he ultimately gives in to the pressure of the crowd. This highlights his moral weakness and his prioritization of political expediency over doing what is right. He fears a potential riot or rebellion if he defies the crowd, which could jeopardize his position with Rome.
Theological Implications: From a Christian perspective, this verse contributes to the understanding of Jesus' sacrifice. His willingness to endure suffering and death, even when innocent, is seen as an act of love and redemption for humanity. It underscores the idea that Jesus was unjustly condemned and died for the sins of the world.
Antisemitism (Important Caution): Throughout history, this passage and similar accounts in the Gospels have been misused to justify antisemitism. It's crucial to understand that the "they" in this verse refers to a specific crowd in Jerusalem at that time, incited by particular religious leaders. It does not represent the entire Jewish people, either then or now. Blaming all Jews for the death of Jesus is a dangerous and harmful misinterpretation of the text.
In conclusion, Matthew 27:23 is a powerful verse that reveals the injustice of Jesus' trial, the manipulation of the crowd, Pilate's moral weakness, and the theological significance of Jesus' sacrifice. It also serves as a warning against the dangers of mob rule and the importance of upholding justice, and it should be interpreted with careful attention to avoid harmful antisemitic interpretations.