Luke 9:21 - But he warned them, and commanded them to tell this to no one,
Select Bible Verse
Filter Categories
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
R
S
T
U
V
W
What does "Luke 9:21" mean?
Luke 9:21, "But he warned them, and commanded them to tell this to no one," refers to Jesus's command to his disciples not to publicly announce that he is the Christ, the Messiah. To understand why, we need to consider the context.
Here's a breakdown of the meaning and the reasons behind Jesus's command:
"He warned them, and commanded them...": This emphasizes the seriousness of Jesus's instruction. He wasn't merely suggesting; he was giving a direct and important command.
"...to tell this to no one": "This" refers to the preceding verses (particularly Luke 9:20) where Peter, speaking for the disciples, declares that Jesus is "the Christ of God." Jesus forbade them from proclaiming this publicly.
Reasons for the Command (Secrecy/Messianic Secret):
Several reasons are commonly given for why Jesus might have wanted to keep his messianic identity quiet, at least for a while:
1. Misunderstanding of the Messiah: The popular expectation of the Messiah was often political and militaristic. Many Jews anticipated a king who would overthrow Roman rule and restore Israel to its former glory. Jesus's mission was different – focused on spiritual liberation, forgiveness of sins, and establishing the Kingdom of God in people's hearts. Premature announcement of his messiahship could lead to misinterpretation and potentially incite a violent revolt against Rome. People could get the wrong idea of what Jesus was trying to do, expecting earthly kingship and power when he was about serving and suffering for humanity's salvation.
2. Timing and His Own Plan: Jesus wanted to control the unfolding of events according to God's plan and his own timetable. He knew when and how he wanted to reveal his messianic identity, and he didn't want his ministry derailed by premature or misguided excitement.
3. Popularity and Crowd Control: Jesus's ministry was already drawing large crowds. A public declaration of his Messiahship might intensify this, making it harder for him to travel, teach, and minister effectively. The pressure from the crowds might also lead to unwanted confrontations with religious or political authorities before he was ready.
4. The "Messianic Secret" as a Literary Device (in some interpretations): Some scholars believe that the "Messianic Secret" (Jesus's repeated commands to silence about his identity) is also a literary device used by the Gospel writers (particularly Mark, but also present in Luke) to:
Create suspense: It builds anticipation for the full revelation of Jesus's identity.
Emphasize the importance of understanding who Jesus truly is: The disciples needed to learn what it meant for Jesus to be the Messiah, not just declare it as a title.
Highlight Jesus's actions over his titles: The focus is on what Jesus does rather than what people call him.
5. Preservation of Jesus' life: Prematurely declaring himself the Messiah could have expedited his arrest and death before he had accomplished his mission.
In Summary:
Luke 9:21 reflects Jesus's intentional approach to revealing his identity as the Messiah. He needed to control the timing and manner of that revelation to prevent misunderstandings, maintain order, and fulfill God's plan for his life and ministry. He wanted people to understand the true nature of his messiahship before it was publicly proclaimed.
Luke 9:21 - But he warned them, and commanded them to tell this to no one,
What does "Luke 9:21" mean?
Luke 9:21, "But he warned them, and commanded them to tell this to no one," refers to Jesus's command to his disciples not to publicly announce that he is the Christ, the Messiah. To understand why, we need to consider the context.
Here's a breakdown of the meaning and the reasons behind Jesus's command:
"He warned them, and commanded them...": This emphasizes the seriousness of Jesus's instruction. He wasn't merely suggesting; he was giving a direct and important command.
"...to tell this to no one": "This" refers to the preceding verses (particularly Luke 9:20) where Peter, speaking for the disciples, declares that Jesus is "the Christ of God." Jesus forbade them from proclaiming this publicly.
Reasons for the Command (Secrecy/Messianic Secret):
Several reasons are commonly given for why Jesus might have wanted to keep his messianic identity quiet, at least for a while:
1. Misunderstanding of the Messiah: The popular expectation of the Messiah was often political and militaristic. Many Jews anticipated a king who would overthrow Roman rule and restore Israel to its former glory. Jesus's mission was different – focused on spiritual liberation, forgiveness of sins, and establishing the Kingdom of God in people's hearts. Premature announcement of his messiahship could lead to misinterpretation and potentially incite a violent revolt against Rome. People could get the wrong idea of what Jesus was trying to do, expecting earthly kingship and power when he was about serving and suffering for humanity's salvation.
2. Timing and His Own Plan: Jesus wanted to control the unfolding of events according to God's plan and his own timetable. He knew when and how he wanted to reveal his messianic identity, and he didn't want his ministry derailed by premature or misguided excitement.
3. Popularity and Crowd Control: Jesus's ministry was already drawing large crowds. A public declaration of his Messiahship might intensify this, making it harder for him to travel, teach, and minister effectively. The pressure from the crowds might also lead to unwanted confrontations with religious or political authorities before he was ready.
4. The "Messianic Secret" as a Literary Device (in some interpretations): Some scholars believe that the "Messianic Secret" (Jesus's repeated commands to silence about his identity) is also a literary device used by the Gospel writers (particularly Mark, but also present in Luke) to:
Create suspense: It builds anticipation for the full revelation of Jesus's identity.
Emphasize the importance of understanding who Jesus truly is: The disciples needed to learn what it meant for Jesus to be the Messiah, not just declare it as a title.
Highlight Jesus's actions over his titles: The focus is on what Jesus does rather than what people call him.
5. Preservation of Jesus' life: Prematurely declaring himself the Messiah could have expedited his arrest and death before he had accomplished his mission.
In Summary:
Luke 9:21 reflects Jesus's intentional approach to revealing his identity as the Messiah. He needed to control the timing and manner of that revelation to prevent misunderstandings, maintain order, and fulfill God's plan for his life and ministry. He wanted people to understand the true nature of his messiahship before it was publicly proclaimed.