Judges 21:16 - Then the elders of the congregation said, “How shall we provide wives for those who remain, since the women are destroyed out of Benjamin?”
Select Bible Verse
Filter Categories
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
R
S
T
U
V
W
What does "Judges 21:16" mean?
This verse is part of a very disturbing and ethically problematic story in the Book of Judges. It follows a brutal civil war between the other Israelite tribes and the tribe of Benjamin. Here's a breakdown of what it means in context:
Context: The other tribes of Israel had vowed not to give their daughters in marriage to men from Benjamin as punishment for a heinous crime committed in Gibeah by Benjamites (specifically, the gang rape and death of a Levite's concubine, as described in Judges 19). They nearly annihilated the entire tribe of Benjamin in battle.
"The elders of the congregation said...": These are the leaders of the other Israelite tribes who were feeling conflicted. They had vowed to punish Benjamin but now realized they had nearly wiped them out.
"How shall we provide wives for those who remain...": This is the core of the verse. The elders are concerned about the long-term survival of the tribe of Benjamin. Without wives, the remaining Benjamite men will not be able to have children, and the tribe will disappear.
"...since the women are destroyed out of Benjamin?": This highlights the problem. The war has decimated the female population of Benjamin. Most women and children would likely have been killed in the fighting. Because of the oath they took they can't give their daughters to the remaining Benjaminite men.
The Problem:
The elders are caught in a bind of their own making. They made a rash oath, and now they realize the severe consequences of their actions. They are desperate to find a solution that allows Benjamin to survive while still technically honoring their oath.
Ethical Concerns:
This entire episode raises serious ethical questions:
Overreaction and Vengeance: The initial crime in Gibeah was horrific, but the other tribes' response was disproportionate and led to further violence and injustice.
Taking Oaths Lightly: The elders made an oath without fully considering the implications, and now they're trying to find loopholes.
Treatment of Women: The women are treated as property or tools to be used for repopulation, with no regard for their own desires or rights. The events that follow this verse (the kidnapping of the women of Jabesh-Gilead and the daughters of Shiloh) are particularly troubling.
In summary, Judges 21:16 reflects the elders' concern about the survival of the tribe of Benjamin after a devastating civil war and the oath the other tribes made. It highlights the dire situation caused by their vow and sets the stage for the morally questionable actions they take to try to resolve the problem. It's a stark reminder of the dangers of rash decisions, the cycle of violence, and the exploitation of women in ancient Israelite society.
Judges 21:16 - Then the elders of the congregation said, “How shall we provide wives for those who remain, since the women are destroyed out of Benjamin?”
What does "Judges 21:16" mean?
This verse is part of a very disturbing and ethically problematic story in the Book of Judges. It follows a brutal civil war between the other Israelite tribes and the tribe of Benjamin. Here's a breakdown of what it means in context:
Context: The other tribes of Israel had vowed not to give their daughters in marriage to men from Benjamin as punishment for a heinous crime committed in Gibeah by Benjamites (specifically, the gang rape and death of a Levite's concubine, as described in Judges 19). They nearly annihilated the entire tribe of Benjamin in battle.
"The elders of the congregation said...": These are the leaders of the other Israelite tribes who were feeling conflicted. They had vowed to punish Benjamin but now realized they had nearly wiped them out.
"How shall we provide wives for those who remain...": This is the core of the verse. The elders are concerned about the long-term survival of the tribe of Benjamin. Without wives, the remaining Benjamite men will not be able to have children, and the tribe will disappear.
"...since the women are destroyed out of Benjamin?": This highlights the problem. The war has decimated the female population of Benjamin. Most women and children would likely have been killed in the fighting. Because of the oath they took they can't give their daughters to the remaining Benjaminite men.
The Problem:
The elders are caught in a bind of their own making. They made a rash oath, and now they realize the severe consequences of their actions. They are desperate to find a solution that allows Benjamin to survive while still technically honoring their oath.
Ethical Concerns:
This entire episode raises serious ethical questions:
Overreaction and Vengeance: The initial crime in Gibeah was horrific, but the other tribes' response was disproportionate and led to further violence and injustice.
Taking Oaths Lightly: The elders made an oath without fully considering the implications, and now they're trying to find loopholes.
Treatment of Women: The women are treated as property or tools to be used for repopulation, with no regard for their own desires or rights. The events that follow this verse (the kidnapping of the women of Jabesh-Gilead and the daughters of Shiloh) are particularly troubling.
In summary, Judges 21:16 reflects the elders' concern about the survival of the tribe of Benjamin after a devastating civil war and the oath the other tribes made. It highlights the dire situation caused by their vow and sets the stage for the morally questionable actions they take to try to resolve the problem. It's a stark reminder of the dangers of rash decisions, the cycle of violence, and the exploitation of women in ancient Israelite society.