John 9:19 - and asked them, “Is this your son, whom you say was born blind? How then does he now see?”

Generated Verse: John 9:19

What does "John 9:19" mean?


This verse is part of the story of Jesus healing a man born blind, found in John chapter 9. It comes after the healed man has returned home and his neighbors are questioning him, wondering if he's really the man they knew was blind.

Here's a breakdown of what the verse means in context:

"and asked them," - This refers to the Jewish authorities (likely Pharisees) who were skeptical of Jesus and his miracles. The neighbors, confused by the healed man, bring him and his parents to the Pharisees for questioning.

"“Is this your son, whom you say was born blind?" - The authorities are directly addressing the parents of the formerly blind man. They are questioning his identity, implying that maybe it's not the same person or that he was never truly blind.

"How then does he now see?”" - This is the central point of the question. The authorities acknowledge the undeniable fact that the man can now see. They are challenging the parents to explain how this seemingly impossible event happened. They are implying that there must be something deceptive or untruthful about the situation. They're trying to figure out if it's a trick, a case of mistaken identity, or something else that doesn't involve a miraculous healing by Jesus.

In essence, the authorities are suspicious and hostile. They are trying to discredit the miracle and, by extension, discredit Jesus. They are using the parents to try to find a weakness or inconsistency in the story so they can dismiss it as a fraud.

The parents' response in the following verses is telling. They confirm he is their son and that he was born blind, but they are afraid to say how he was healed because they know the authorities have declared that anyone who acknowledges Jesus as the Messiah will be expelled from the synagogue. They pass the responsibility of explanation back to their son, who can speak for himself.

What categories does "John 9:19" have?