Isaiah 21:11 - The burden of Dumah. One calls to me out of Seir, “Watchman, what of the night? Watchman, what of the night?”
Select Bible Verse
Filter Categories
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
R
S
T
U
V
W
What does "Isaiah 21:11" mean?
Isaiah 21:11 is a cryptic and debated verse, part of an oracle (prophecy) concerning Dumah. Let's break down the possible meanings and interpretations:
Literal Interpretation:
Dumah: This is generally understood to refer to a region or tribe. While there are debates about its exact location, it's often associated with Edom (also called Seir), located southeast of Israel. Dumah is a play on words. It means "silence" or "stillness" in Hebrew.
Seir: This is another name for Edom, the mountainous region southeast of the Dead Sea.
"One calls to me out of Seir": Someone (likely an Edomite) is calling to the prophet (or a prophetic watchman). The fact that the call comes out of Edom/Seir is significant, suggesting distress or urgency coming from that region.
"Watchman, what of the night? Watchman, what of the night?" This is the core of the verse. The Edomite asks the watchman (prophet) about the state of the "night." "Night" is a common metaphor for times of trouble, darkness, oppression, and uncertainty. The repeated question emphasizes the anxiety and urgency of the inquirer. They desperately want to know what the future holds, how much longer the suffering will last.
Possible Interpretations (Beyond the Literal):
1. A Question of Timing: The Edomites are in a state of turmoil, possibly under threat of invasion or experiencing internal strife. They are asking the prophet if the "night" (the period of hardship) is nearing its end. They seek reassurance that dawn (a period of peace and prosperity) is coming. The repetition highlights their anxiety and desire for an answer.
2. A Plea for Guidance: The Edomites may be seeking guidance from the prophet. They are asking for insight into their situation and advice on how to navigate the "night." They recognize the prophet's (or watchman's) ability to see beyond the immediate darkness and offer direction.
3. A Vague Prophecy of Doom: Some interpretations suggest that the question is rhetorical, implying that the "watchman" (the prophet) has no good news to deliver. The "night" will continue, and there is no immediate relief for Dumah/Edom. This aligns with the overall theme of judgment found in some parts of Isaiah.
4. A Foreshadowing of Edom's Downfall: Given the context of Isaiah's prophecies, it's possible that this verse is a subtle foreshadowing of Edom's eventual subjugation or destruction. The question about the "night" implies a looming threat, and the watchman's response (found in the next verse, Isaiah 21:12) does not offer definitive comfort.
Isaiah 21:12 (The Response):
It's crucial to consider the next verse in understanding the meaning: "The watchman says, “Morning comes, and also the night. If you will inquire, inquire; come back again.”
This response is ambiguous and frustrating:
"Morning comes, and also the night": This is not a clear promise of deliverance. It suggests a cyclical pattern – periods of light (morning) and darkness (night) will continue. There is no guarantee of lasting peace or prosperity. It could mean both good and bad times will come.
"If you will inquire, inquire; come back again": This seems to suggest that further inquiry is welcome, but it also implies that there is no easy answer or immediate solution. They need to keep seeking.
In summary:
Isaiah 21:11-12 is a short but impactful passage that paints a picture of a people (Dumah/Edom) in distress, anxiously seeking answers about their future. The prophet's (or watchman's) response is cryptic and offers no easy solutions, suggesting a complex and uncertain future for the region. The passage raises questions about the nature of prophecy, the responsibility of watchmen/prophets, and the human desire for clarity in times of hardship. It's open to interpretation, but the core message is about a people facing a difficult period and seeking insight into what lies ahead.
Isaiah 21:11 - The burden of Dumah. One calls to me out of Seir, “Watchman, what of the night? Watchman, what of the night?”
What does "Isaiah 21:11" mean?
Isaiah 21:11 is a cryptic and debated verse, part of an oracle (prophecy) concerning Dumah. Let's break down the possible meanings and interpretations:
Literal Interpretation:
Dumah: This is generally understood to refer to a region or tribe. While there are debates about its exact location, it's often associated with Edom (also called Seir), located southeast of Israel. Dumah is a play on words. It means "silence" or "stillness" in Hebrew.
Seir: This is another name for Edom, the mountainous region southeast of the Dead Sea.
"One calls to me out of Seir": Someone (likely an Edomite) is calling to the prophet (or a prophetic watchman). The fact that the call comes out of Edom/Seir is significant, suggesting distress or urgency coming from that region.
"Watchman, what of the night? Watchman, what of the night?" This is the core of the verse. The Edomite asks the watchman (prophet) about the state of the "night." "Night" is a common metaphor for times of trouble, darkness, oppression, and uncertainty. The repeated question emphasizes the anxiety and urgency of the inquirer. They desperately want to know what the future holds, how much longer the suffering will last.
Possible Interpretations (Beyond the Literal):
1. A Question of Timing: The Edomites are in a state of turmoil, possibly under threat of invasion or experiencing internal strife. They are asking the prophet if the "night" (the period of hardship) is nearing its end. They seek reassurance that dawn (a period of peace and prosperity) is coming. The repetition highlights their anxiety and desire for an answer.
2. A Plea for Guidance: The Edomites may be seeking guidance from the prophet. They are asking for insight into their situation and advice on how to navigate the "night." They recognize the prophet's (or watchman's) ability to see beyond the immediate darkness and offer direction.
3. A Vague Prophecy of Doom: Some interpretations suggest that the question is rhetorical, implying that the "watchman" (the prophet) has no good news to deliver. The "night" will continue, and there is no immediate relief for Dumah/Edom. This aligns with the overall theme of judgment found in some parts of Isaiah.
4. A Foreshadowing of Edom's Downfall: Given the context of Isaiah's prophecies, it's possible that this verse is a subtle foreshadowing of Edom's eventual subjugation or destruction. The question about the "night" implies a looming threat, and the watchman's response (found in the next verse, Isaiah 21:12) does not offer definitive comfort.
Isaiah 21:12 (The Response):
It's crucial to consider the next verse in understanding the meaning: "The watchman says, “Morning comes, and also the night. If you will inquire, inquire; come back again.”
This response is ambiguous and frustrating:
"Morning comes, and also the night": This is not a clear promise of deliverance. It suggests a cyclical pattern – periods of light (morning) and darkness (night) will continue. There is no guarantee of lasting peace or prosperity. It could mean both good and bad times will come.
"If you will inquire, inquire; come back again": This seems to suggest that further inquiry is welcome, but it also implies that there is no easy answer or immediate solution. They need to keep seeking.
In summary:
Isaiah 21:11-12 is a short but impactful passage that paints a picture of a people (Dumah/Edom) in distress, anxiously seeking answers about their future. The prophet's (or watchman's) response is cryptic and offers no easy solutions, suggesting a complex and uncertain future for the region. The passage raises questions about the nature of prophecy, the responsibility of watchmen/prophets, and the human desire for clarity in times of hardship. It's open to interpretation, but the core message is about a people facing a difficult period and seeking insight into what lies ahead.