Genesis 44:5 - Isn’t this that from which my lord drinks, and by which he indeed divines? You have done evil in so doing.’”
Select Bible Verse
Filter Categories
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
R
S
T
U
V
W
What does "Genesis 44:5" mean?
Genesis 44:5 is part of the story of Joseph testing his brothers after they come to Egypt to buy grain, unaware that the powerful official they are dealing with is their long-lost brother. Let's break down the verse:
"Isn't this that from which my lord drinks...": This refers to a silver cup. Joseph, as the steward of Egypt, is accusing his brothers of stealing a valuable cup belonging to him, or more accurately, to the Pharaoh's household that he managed. The cup was likely used for drinking wine or water.
"...and by which he indeed divines?": This is the most intriguing and debated part. It suggests that Joseph used the cup for divination, a practice of seeking knowledge of the future or hidden things through supernatural means. Divination was common in ancient cultures, including Egypt. How Joseph might have used the cup for divination is not described in the Bible. Some theories include:
Looking into the cup's reflection: Perhaps Joseph interpreted patterns or visions seen in the liquid or the polished surface of the cup.
Observing the dregs: Similar to reading tea leaves, Joseph might have looked at the sediment remaining in the cup after drinking.
Symbolic Use: It's possible the divination aspect was a pretense, a way to further manipulate his brothers and test their reactions. He might not have actually used the cup for divination, but merely claimed to do so to create a convincing scenario.
"You have done evil in so doing.": This is the accusation of theft and deception. Stealing the cup was bad enough, but stealing a cup used for divination added another layer of offense, potentially implying disrespect for Joseph's authority and beliefs.
Context within the Larger Story:
Joseph's actions toward his brothers in this whole episode are complex. He's testing them to see if they've changed since they sold him into slavery years earlier. He wants to know if they're still cruel and self-serving, or if they now value family and brotherhood. The stolen cup accusation is a key part of this test. By making the situation appear dire (potential slavery for the thief), Joseph hopes to reveal the true character of his brothers, particularly Judah, who previously proposed selling Joseph into slavery in the first place. The cup serves as a device in this test.
Genesis 44:5 - Isn’t this that from which my lord drinks, and by which he indeed divines? You have done evil in so doing.’”
What does "Genesis 44:5" mean?
Genesis 44:5 is part of the story of Joseph testing his brothers after they come to Egypt to buy grain, unaware that the powerful official they are dealing with is their long-lost brother. Let's break down the verse:
"Isn't this that from which my lord drinks...": This refers to a silver cup. Joseph, as the steward of Egypt, is accusing his brothers of stealing a valuable cup belonging to him, or more accurately, to the Pharaoh's household that he managed. The cup was likely used for drinking wine or water.
"...and by which he indeed divines?": This is the most intriguing and debated part. It suggests that Joseph used the cup for divination, a practice of seeking knowledge of the future or hidden things through supernatural means. Divination was common in ancient cultures, including Egypt. How Joseph might have used the cup for divination is not described in the Bible. Some theories include:
Looking into the cup's reflection: Perhaps Joseph interpreted patterns or visions seen in the liquid or the polished surface of the cup.
Observing the dregs: Similar to reading tea leaves, Joseph might have looked at the sediment remaining in the cup after drinking.
Symbolic Use: It's possible the divination aspect was a pretense, a way to further manipulate his brothers and test their reactions. He might not have actually used the cup for divination, but merely claimed to do so to create a convincing scenario.
"You have done evil in so doing.": This is the accusation of theft and deception. Stealing the cup was bad enough, but stealing a cup used for divination added another layer of offense, potentially implying disrespect for Joseph's authority and beliefs.
Context within the Larger Story:
Joseph's actions toward his brothers in this whole episode are complex. He's testing them to see if they've changed since they sold him into slavery years earlier. He wants to know if they're still cruel and self-serving, or if they now value family and brotherhood. The stolen cup accusation is a key part of this test. By making the situation appear dire (potential slavery for the thief), Joseph hopes to reveal the true character of his brothers, particularly Judah, who previously proposed selling Joseph into slavery in the first place. The cup serves as a device in this test.