Genesis 37:26 - Judah said to his brothers, “What profit is it if we kill our brother and conceal his blood?
Select Bible Verse
Filter Categories
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
R
S
T
U
V
W
What does "Genesis 37:26" mean?
This verse from Genesis 37:26 is a pivotal moment in the story of Joseph and his brothers. Here's a breakdown of its meaning:
Context: Joseph's brothers, motivated by jealousy and resentment towards Joseph's favored status and prophetic dreams, were plotting to kill him. They had already seized him and were considering their options.
Judah's Interjection: Judah, one of the brothers, speaks up. He is offering an alternative to outright murder.
"What profit is it if we kill our brother and conceal his blood?" This is the core of the verse, and Judah is making a pragmatic argument:
"What profit is it...?" He's questioning the practical benefit of their plan. He's appealing to their self-interest, suggesting that killing Joseph might not be the most advantageous course of action.
"...if we kill our brother..." This acknowledges their intention of killing Joseph.
"...and conceal his blood?" "Concealing his blood" means hiding the evidence of their crime. Judah recognizes that they would have to cover up the murder to avoid being discovered and punished.
Underlying Meaning: Judah is suggesting that murder is a messy and risky business. He's implying that it would be difficult to completely hide their crime and that the potential consequences (guilt, punishment from their father Jacob) might outweigh any satisfaction they get from killing Joseph.
Judah's Motivation: It's debatable whether Judah's motivation is truly altruistic. He might have been slightly less vindictive than the others, or he might have simply been more concerned about the practical consequences of their actions. Some interpret it as a genuine desire to spare Joseph's life, while others see it as a more self-serving attempt to avoid the risks associated with murder.
Significance in the Story: Judah's statement is crucial because it changes the course of events. Instead of killing Joseph, the brothers decide to sell him into slavery to a passing caravan of Ishmaelites (or Midianites, depending on the account). This act, while still morally reprehensible, spares Joseph's life and ultimately leads to his rise to power in Egypt, which later saves his family from famine.
In summary, Genesis 37:26 highlights Judah's attempt to dissuade his brothers from committing murder by appealing to their self-interest and suggesting a less risky, more profitable alternative. It marks a turning point in the story of Joseph and sets the stage for the events that follow.
Genesis 37:26 - Judah said to his brothers, “What profit is it if we kill our brother and conceal his blood?
What does "Genesis 37:26" mean?
This verse from Genesis 37:26 is a pivotal moment in the story of Joseph and his brothers. Here's a breakdown of its meaning:
Context: Joseph's brothers, motivated by jealousy and resentment towards Joseph's favored status and prophetic dreams, were plotting to kill him. They had already seized him and were considering their options.
Judah's Interjection: Judah, one of the brothers, speaks up. He is offering an alternative to outright murder.
"What profit is it if we kill our brother and conceal his blood?" This is the core of the verse, and Judah is making a pragmatic argument:
"What profit is it...?" He's questioning the practical benefit of their plan. He's appealing to their self-interest, suggesting that killing Joseph might not be the most advantageous course of action.
"...if we kill our brother..." This acknowledges their intention of killing Joseph.
"...and conceal his blood?" "Concealing his blood" means hiding the evidence of their crime. Judah recognizes that they would have to cover up the murder to avoid being discovered and punished.
Underlying Meaning: Judah is suggesting that murder is a messy and risky business. He's implying that it would be difficult to completely hide their crime and that the potential consequences (guilt, punishment from their father Jacob) might outweigh any satisfaction they get from killing Joseph.
Judah's Motivation: It's debatable whether Judah's motivation is truly altruistic. He might have been slightly less vindictive than the others, or he might have simply been more concerned about the practical consequences of their actions. Some interpret it as a genuine desire to spare Joseph's life, while others see it as a more self-serving attempt to avoid the risks associated with murder.
Significance in the Story: Judah's statement is crucial because it changes the course of events. Instead of killing Joseph, the brothers decide to sell him into slavery to a passing caravan of Ishmaelites (or Midianites, depending on the account). This act, while still morally reprehensible, spares Joseph's life and ultimately leads to his rise to power in Egypt, which later saves his family from famine.
In summary, Genesis 37:26 highlights Judah's attempt to dissuade his brothers from committing murder by appealing to their self-interest and suggesting a less risky, more profitable alternative. It marks a turning point in the story of Joseph and sets the stage for the events that follow.