Exodus 22:9 - For every matter of trespass, whether it is for ox, for donkey, for sheep, for clothing, or for any kind of lost thing, about which one says, ‘This is mine,’ the cause of both parties shall come before God. He whom God condemns shall pay double to his neighbor.

Generated Verse: Exodus 22:9

What does "Exodus 22:9" mean?


Exodus 22:9 deals with the legal consequences of disputes over lost or stolen property. Let's break it down:

"For every matter of trespass..." This introduces a general principle applicable to a wide range of disputes. The term "trespass" here encompasses any situation where someone's property has been taken or is being wrongfully claimed by another.

"...whether it is for ox, for donkey, for sheep, for clothing, or for any kind of lost thing..." This provides specific examples to illustrate the scope of the law. It covers livestock (ox, donkey, sheep), personal belongings (clothing), and a general category of "any kind of lost thing." This makes it clear that the principle applies to a broad spectrum of property disputes.

"...about which one says, ‘This is mine,’..." This highlights the core of the dispute: a claim of ownership. Two parties are contending over the same item, each asserting their right to it.

"...the cause of both parties shall come before God." This is a crucial point. It means the dispute would be brought before judges or elders who were considered representatives of God and were responsible for dispensing justice according to divine law. The legal proceedings were understood as a way to discern God's will in the matter. It implies a serious and formal process of adjudication, not just a casual argument. The phrase "before God" can also be interpreted as a place of worship where the elders made judgement.

"He whom God condemns shall pay double to his neighbor." This establishes the penalty for the party deemed guilty by the judges. The "condemned" party must pay double the value of the lost or stolen item to the rightful owner. This was a significant deterrent, intended to discourage theft and false claims.

In summary, this verse outlines a system for resolving property disputes in ancient Israel. When two parties claim the same lost or stolen item, they must present their case to judges acting as representatives of God. The guilty party, as determined by the judges, is obligated to pay double the value of the item to the rightful owner.

Key Interpretations and Context:

Justice and Deterrence: The law aimed to provide a fair means of resolving disputes and to deter theft and false claims through the penalty of double restitution.
Role of Judges: The judges played a critical role in discerning the truth and applying the law fairly. Their decisions were understood to reflect God's judgment.
Social Order: This law contributed to the maintenance of social order by providing a mechanism for resolving conflicts peacefully and justly.
Value of Property: The emphasis on restitution highlights the importance of private property in ancient Israelite society.

This verse provides insight into the legal and social norms of ancient Israel, emphasizing the importance of justice, fairness, and the protection of property rights.