Deuteronomy 23:2 - A person born of a forbidden union shall not enter into Yahweh’s assembly; even to the tenth generation shall no one of his enter into Yahweh’s assembly.
Select Bible Verse
Filter Categories
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
R
S
T
U
V
W
What does "Deuteronomy 23:2" mean?
Deuteronomy 23:2 states: "A person born of a forbidden union shall not enter into Yahweh’s assembly; even to the tenth generation shall no one of his enter into Yahweh’s assembly."
This verse prohibits individuals born from certain types of unions from participating fully in the religious and civic life of the Israelite community. This exclusion extends to their descendants for ten generations.
Here's a breakdown of the key elements and some common interpretations:
"A person born of a forbidden union": This is the most debated part. The Hebrew word translated as "forbidden union" is mamzer. Its precise meaning is uncertain, leading to varying interpretations. Potential meanings include:
Illegitimate child: Born out of wedlock, particularly from incestuous or adulterous relationships (based on Lev. 18 & 20).
Child of incest: Specifically, the offspring of incestuous relationships.
Child of certain mixed marriages: Although Deuteronomy 7 warns against intermarriage with Canaanites, some interpret mamzer to encompass such unions. However, this is less likely, as the broader biblical narrative sometimes allows for integration of foreigners through conversion.
Child of prostitution: The Talmud expands this to include the child of a Jewish woman and a non-Jewish man.
It is important to note: that the precise definition and application of this term has been heavily debated throughout Jewish history and continues to be a topic of discussion.
"Shall not enter into Yahweh’s assembly": This phrase implies exclusion from full participation in the community's religious life and likely also civil matters. It would potentially restrict access to certain privileges, leadership positions, and social standing. It does not necessarily mean complete ostracization or denial of basic human rights.
"Even to the tenth generation shall no one of his enter into Yahweh’s assembly": This highlights the severity and long-lasting consequences of the perceived transgression. The restriction extends beyond the individual to their descendants for ten generations. Ten generations in ancient times would have been a very long time, essentially permanently barring a lineage.
Interpretations and Significance:
Maintaining Purity: One key motivation behind this law could be the desire to maintain the purity and integrity of the Israelite community, both religiously and ethnically. It reflects a concern for preserving the unique covenant relationship between Yahweh and the Israelites.
Discouraging Forbidden Relationships: The law could serve as a deterrent against illicit relationships by imposing social and religious penalties on those involved and their offspring.
Social Control: Some scholars argue that such laws were used to reinforce social norms and hierarchies, controlling marriage practices and maintaining social order.
Potential for Cruelty: Critics of this verse highlight the potential for unfairness and cruelty. It can be seen as punishing individuals for the actions of their parents, creating a permanent underclass based on circumstances of birth.
Changing Interpretations in Later Judaism: Jewish tradition has wrestled with the interpretation and application of this verse throughout history. The Talmud offers interpretations that both restrict and potentially mitigate its severity. Some argue for a more compassionate reading, focusing on rehabilitation and inclusion rather than permanent exclusion.
Important Considerations:
Historical Context: Understanding the historical context of ancient Israel is crucial. Social structures, religious beliefs, and the need for tribal cohesion all played a role in shaping such laws.
Theological Implications: The verse raises questions about divine justice, collective punishment, and the nature of God's mercy and forgiveness.
Relevance Today: Modern interpretations often focus on the ethical implications of judging individuals based on their origins and the importance of promoting inclusivity and compassion.
In conclusion, Deuteronomy 23:2 is a complex and controversial verse that prohibits individuals born from certain unions and their descendants for ten generations from fully participating in the Israelite community. Its exact meaning and application have been debated throughout history, with interpretations ranging from strict enforcement of social and religious norms to more compassionate readings that emphasize inclusion and rehabilitation. The verse raises important questions about purity, justice, and the treatment of marginalized individuals within a community.
Deuteronomy 23:2 - A person born of a forbidden union shall not enter into Yahweh’s assembly; even to the tenth generation shall no one of his enter into Yahweh’s assembly.
What does "Deuteronomy 23:2" mean?
Deuteronomy 23:2 states: "A person born of a forbidden union shall not enter into Yahweh’s assembly; even to the tenth generation shall no one of his enter into Yahweh’s assembly."
This verse prohibits individuals born from certain types of unions from participating fully in the religious and civic life of the Israelite community. This exclusion extends to their descendants for ten generations.
Here's a breakdown of the key elements and some common interpretations:
"A person born of a forbidden union": This is the most debated part. The Hebrew word translated as "forbidden union" is mamzer. Its precise meaning is uncertain, leading to varying interpretations. Potential meanings include:
Illegitimate child: Born out of wedlock, particularly from incestuous or adulterous relationships (based on Lev. 18 & 20).
Child of incest: Specifically, the offspring of incestuous relationships.
Child of certain mixed marriages: Although Deuteronomy 7 warns against intermarriage with Canaanites, some interpret mamzer to encompass such unions. However, this is less likely, as the broader biblical narrative sometimes allows for integration of foreigners through conversion.
Child of prostitution: The Talmud expands this to include the child of a Jewish woman and a non-Jewish man.
It is important to note: that the precise definition and application of this term has been heavily debated throughout Jewish history and continues to be a topic of discussion.
"Shall not enter into Yahweh’s assembly": This phrase implies exclusion from full participation in the community's religious life and likely also civil matters. It would potentially restrict access to certain privileges, leadership positions, and social standing. It does not necessarily mean complete ostracization or denial of basic human rights.
"Even to the tenth generation shall no one of his enter into Yahweh’s assembly": This highlights the severity and long-lasting consequences of the perceived transgression. The restriction extends beyond the individual to their descendants for ten generations. Ten generations in ancient times would have been a very long time, essentially permanently barring a lineage.
Interpretations and Significance:
Maintaining Purity: One key motivation behind this law could be the desire to maintain the purity and integrity of the Israelite community, both religiously and ethnically. It reflects a concern for preserving the unique covenant relationship between Yahweh and the Israelites.
Discouraging Forbidden Relationships: The law could serve as a deterrent against illicit relationships by imposing social and religious penalties on those involved and their offspring.
Social Control: Some scholars argue that such laws were used to reinforce social norms and hierarchies, controlling marriage practices and maintaining social order.
Potential for Cruelty: Critics of this verse highlight the potential for unfairness and cruelty. It can be seen as punishing individuals for the actions of their parents, creating a permanent underclass based on circumstances of birth.
Changing Interpretations in Later Judaism: Jewish tradition has wrestled with the interpretation and application of this verse throughout history. The Talmud offers interpretations that both restrict and potentially mitigate its severity. Some argue for a more compassionate reading, focusing on rehabilitation and inclusion rather than permanent exclusion.
Important Considerations:
Historical Context: Understanding the historical context of ancient Israel is crucial. Social structures, religious beliefs, and the need for tribal cohesion all played a role in shaping such laws.
Theological Implications: The verse raises questions about divine justice, collective punishment, and the nature of God's mercy and forgiveness.
Relevance Today: Modern interpretations often focus on the ethical implications of judging individuals based on their origins and the importance of promoting inclusivity and compassion.
In conclusion, Deuteronomy 23:2 is a complex and controversial verse that prohibits individuals born from certain unions and their descendants for ten generations from fully participating in the Israelite community. Its exact meaning and application have been debated throughout history, with interpretations ranging from strict enforcement of social and religious norms to more compassionate readings that emphasize inclusion and rehabilitation. The verse raises important questions about purity, justice, and the treatment of marginalized individuals within a community.