1 samuel 6:19 - He struck of the men of Beth Shemesh, because they had looked into Yahweh’s ark, he struck fifty thousand seventy of the men. Then the people mourned, because Yahweh had struck the people with a great slaughter.
Select Bible Verse
Filter Categories
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
R
S
T
U
V
W
What does "1 samuel 6:19" mean?
This verse from 1 Samuel 6:19 is a particularly challenging and often debated passage. Here's a breakdown of what it says and some of the interpretations:
What the Verse Says:
"He struck of the men of Beth Shemesh...": This means that God (Yahweh) inflicted a punishment on the people of Beth Shemesh, a town in ancient Israel.
"...because they had looked into Yahweh’s ark...": This is the reason given for the punishment. The Ark of the Covenant was considered the holiest object in Israel, representing God's presence. It was to be treated with extreme reverence and handled only by authorized individuals (Levites). Looking inside was a serious transgression.
"...he struck fifty thousand seventy of the men.": This is the controversial part. The verse states the number of people who died as a result of looking into the Ark. The Hebrew text is a bit unclear and has been interpreted in various ways, as we'll discuss below.
"Then the people mourned, because Yahweh had struck the people with a great slaughter.": This emphasizes the widespread grief and recognition that the deaths were a consequence of their actions, attributed to divine punishment.
Interpretations and Issues:
1. The Number "Fifty Thousand Seventy":
Scribal Error: Many scholars believe the number is likely a scribal error. Copying ancient texts was done by hand, and mistakes could easily occur. The extremely high number (50,070) seems improbable given the size of Beth Shemesh and the general context of the story.
Alternative Readings: Some ancient versions of the Bible (like the Septuagint) have different numbers, such as "seventy men." This suggests that the original number might have been much smaller.
Exaggeration: It's also possible that the number is an exaggeration to emphasize the severity of God's judgment. Ancient writers sometimes used large numbers to convey a sense of awe and seriousness.
"Fifty Chief Men": Some interpret the Hebrew differently to mean "seventy men, (and) fifty chief men", separating the seventy men who looked into the ark from the fifty important officials.
2. The Sin of Looking:
Disrespect for Holiness: The primary sin was a lack of reverence for God's holiness. The Ark was not to be treated casually or out of curiosity. It was a symbol of God's presence and power.
Unauthorized Access: Only Levites were permitted to handle or be near the Ark. The people of Beth Shemesh were likely not authorized, making their act a violation of God's law.
Understanding the Covenant: God made a covenant with the Israelites, and this covenant came with responsibilities. Disobeying God's commands had consequences.
3. The Severity of the Punishment:
Divine Justice: The severity of the punishment raises questions about God's justice. However, the text is clear that the people had violated God's commands and treated a sacred object with disrespect.
Warning to Others: The incident served as a warning to all Israel about the importance of respecting God's holiness and obeying his laws.
Symbolic Significance: Some argue that the deaths symbolize the spiritual consequences of approaching God in an improper or irreverent manner.
In Conclusion:
The verse from 1 Samuel 6:19 highlights the importance of respecting God's holiness and obeying his commands. The exact number of deaths is debated, and likely the passage should be interpreted carefully.
1 samuel 6:19 - He struck of the men of Beth Shemesh, because they had looked into Yahweh’s ark, he struck fifty thousand seventy of the men. Then the people mourned, because Yahweh had struck the people with a great slaughter.
What does "1 samuel 6:19" mean?
This verse from 1 Samuel 6:19 is a particularly challenging and often debated passage. Here's a breakdown of what it says and some of the interpretations:
What the Verse Says:
"He struck of the men of Beth Shemesh...": This means that God (Yahweh) inflicted a punishment on the people of Beth Shemesh, a town in ancient Israel.
"...because they had looked into Yahweh’s ark...": This is the reason given for the punishment. The Ark of the Covenant was considered the holiest object in Israel, representing God's presence. It was to be treated with extreme reverence and handled only by authorized individuals (Levites). Looking inside was a serious transgression.
"...he struck fifty thousand seventy of the men.": This is the controversial part. The verse states the number of people who died as a result of looking into the Ark. The Hebrew text is a bit unclear and has been interpreted in various ways, as we'll discuss below.
"Then the people mourned, because Yahweh had struck the people with a great slaughter.": This emphasizes the widespread grief and recognition that the deaths were a consequence of their actions, attributed to divine punishment.
Interpretations and Issues:
1. The Number "Fifty Thousand Seventy":
Scribal Error: Many scholars believe the number is likely a scribal error. Copying ancient texts was done by hand, and mistakes could easily occur. The extremely high number (50,070) seems improbable given the size of Beth Shemesh and the general context of the story.
Alternative Readings: Some ancient versions of the Bible (like the Septuagint) have different numbers, such as "seventy men." This suggests that the original number might have been much smaller.
Exaggeration: It's also possible that the number is an exaggeration to emphasize the severity of God's judgment. Ancient writers sometimes used large numbers to convey a sense of awe and seriousness.
"Fifty Chief Men": Some interpret the Hebrew differently to mean "seventy men, (and) fifty chief men", separating the seventy men who looked into the ark from the fifty important officials.
2. The Sin of Looking:
Disrespect for Holiness: The primary sin was a lack of reverence for God's holiness. The Ark was not to be treated casually or out of curiosity. It was a symbol of God's presence and power.
Unauthorized Access: Only Levites were permitted to handle or be near the Ark. The people of Beth Shemesh were likely not authorized, making their act a violation of God's law.
Understanding the Covenant: God made a covenant with the Israelites, and this covenant came with responsibilities. Disobeying God's commands had consequences.
3. The Severity of the Punishment:
Divine Justice: The severity of the punishment raises questions about God's justice. However, the text is clear that the people had violated God's commands and treated a sacred object with disrespect.
Warning to Others: The incident served as a warning to all Israel about the importance of respecting God's holiness and obeying his laws.
Symbolic Significance: Some argue that the deaths symbolize the spiritual consequences of approaching God in an improper or irreverent manner.
In Conclusion:
The verse from 1 Samuel 6:19 highlights the importance of respecting God's holiness and obeying his commands. The exact number of deaths is debated, and likely the passage should be interpreted carefully.