1 samuel 28:13 - The king said to her, “Don’t be afraid! What do you see?” The woman said to Saul, “I see a god coming up out of the earth.”
Select Bible Verse
Filter Categories
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
R
S
T
U
V
W
What does "1 samuel 28:13" mean?
This verse from 1 Samuel 28:13 is a key part of the story of Saul's consultation with the witch (or medium) of Endor. Here's a breakdown of its meaning and context:
Context: Saul, the king of Israel, is facing a dire situation. The Philistines are massing for battle, and Saul feels abandoned by God. He desperately seeks guidance, but God is not answering his prayers or through prophets. Desperate, Saul seeks out a medium (witch) to conjure the spirit of the deceased prophet Samuel.
"The king said to her, 'Don’t be afraid! What do you see?'": Saul is disguising himself (so the witch won't recognize him) and is trying to reassure her. This is ironic because he is the one violating God's law by seeking out a medium, and he should be the one afraid. He's also anxious to know what she sees.
"The woman said to Saul, 'I see a god coming up out of the earth.'": This is the crux of the verse. There's considerable debate about what the woman actually sees and what she thinks she sees:
Possible Interpretations:
A Divine Being: The word translated as "god" (elohim in Hebrew) can refer to divine beings, deities, or sometimes even powerful figures. Some interpret this to mean she genuinely saw a spirit or supernatural entity rising from the ground.
Samuel's Spirit: The majority interpretation is that the woman's words suggest she saw Samuel's spirit. This raises further questions about the nature of this encounter – was it truly Samuel, a demon impersonating Samuel, or just a conjured vision?
Her Interpretation: It's crucial to remember that the woman is a medium. Her interpretation of what she sees is filtered through her beliefs and practices. She might genuinely believe she's summoning a god or spirit, regardless of what the reality is.
A Trick or Scam: A more cynical interpretation suggests that the woman was a charlatan who could detect the presence of Saul (perhaps by her ability to read people) and sought to manipulate the situation. She may have feigned the vision to impress him.
"Coming up out of the earth": The phrase indicates that the entity appears to be rising from the underworld, the traditional dwelling place of the dead in ancient Israelite belief.
Significance:
Saul's Desperation: This verse highlights Saul's utter desperation and his willingness to disregard God's law to gain some advantage.
Ambiguity of the Supernatural: The story deliberately leaves the nature of the apparition ambiguous. It's unclear whether the woman genuinely contacted Samuel's spirit or if it was a deception.
Condemnation of Divination: The narrative ultimately serves as a condemnation of divination and consulting mediums. Saul's actions are seen as a grave sin that contributes to his downfall.
Theological Implications: The encounter raises questions about the afterlife, the possibility of communicating with the dead, and the nature of spiritual forces. However, it's important to interpret this passage within the broader context of the Bible, which generally discourages such practices.
In conclusion, 1 Samuel 28:13 is a pivotal verse in a complex and controversial story. It underscores Saul's desperation, the ambiguity surrounding supernatural encounters, and the biblical condemnation of divination. The phrase "I see a god coming up out of the earth" sets the stage for the appearance of what Saul believes to be Samuel, and the subsequent message that seals Saul's fate.
1 samuel 28:13 - The king said to her, “Don’t be afraid! What do you see?” The woman said to Saul, “I see a god coming up out of the earth.”
What does "1 samuel 28:13" mean?
This verse from 1 Samuel 28:13 is a key part of the story of Saul's consultation with the witch (or medium) of Endor. Here's a breakdown of its meaning and context:
Context: Saul, the king of Israel, is facing a dire situation. The Philistines are massing for battle, and Saul feels abandoned by God. He desperately seeks guidance, but God is not answering his prayers or through prophets. Desperate, Saul seeks out a medium (witch) to conjure the spirit of the deceased prophet Samuel.
"The king said to her, 'Don’t be afraid! What do you see?'": Saul is disguising himself (so the witch won't recognize him) and is trying to reassure her. This is ironic because he is the one violating God's law by seeking out a medium, and he should be the one afraid. He's also anxious to know what she sees.
"The woman said to Saul, 'I see a god coming up out of the earth.'": This is the crux of the verse. There's considerable debate about what the woman actually sees and what she thinks she sees:
Possible Interpretations:
A Divine Being: The word translated as "god" (elohim in Hebrew) can refer to divine beings, deities, or sometimes even powerful figures. Some interpret this to mean she genuinely saw a spirit or supernatural entity rising from the ground.
Samuel's Spirit: The majority interpretation is that the woman's words suggest she saw Samuel's spirit. This raises further questions about the nature of this encounter – was it truly Samuel, a demon impersonating Samuel, or just a conjured vision?
Her Interpretation: It's crucial to remember that the woman is a medium. Her interpretation of what she sees is filtered through her beliefs and practices. She might genuinely believe she's summoning a god or spirit, regardless of what the reality is.
A Trick or Scam: A more cynical interpretation suggests that the woman was a charlatan who could detect the presence of Saul (perhaps by her ability to read people) and sought to manipulate the situation. She may have feigned the vision to impress him.
"Coming up out of the earth": The phrase indicates that the entity appears to be rising from the underworld, the traditional dwelling place of the dead in ancient Israelite belief.
Significance:
Saul's Desperation: This verse highlights Saul's utter desperation and his willingness to disregard God's law to gain some advantage.
Ambiguity of the Supernatural: The story deliberately leaves the nature of the apparition ambiguous. It's unclear whether the woman genuinely contacted Samuel's spirit or if it was a deception.
Condemnation of Divination: The narrative ultimately serves as a condemnation of divination and consulting mediums. Saul's actions are seen as a grave sin that contributes to his downfall.
Theological Implications: The encounter raises questions about the afterlife, the possibility of communicating with the dead, and the nature of spiritual forces. However, it's important to interpret this passage within the broader context of the Bible, which generally discourages such practices.
In conclusion, 1 Samuel 28:13 is a pivotal verse in a complex and controversial story. It underscores Saul's desperation, the ambiguity surrounding supernatural encounters, and the biblical condemnation of divination. The phrase "I see a god coming up out of the earth" sets the stage for the appearance of what Saul believes to be Samuel, and the subsequent message that seals Saul's fate.