1 samuel 1:8 - Elkanah her husband said to her, “Hannah, why do you weep? Why don’t you eat? Why is your heart grieved? Am I not better to you than ten sons?”
Select Bible Verse
Filter Categories
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
R
S
T
U
V
W
What does "1 samuel 1:8" mean?
This verse from 1 Samuel 1:8 is a poignant moment where Elkanah tries to comfort his wife, Hannah, who is deeply distressed because she is barren and cannot have children. Let's break it down:
"Elkanah her husband said to her, “Hannah, why do you weep?" Elkanah observes Hannah's sorrow and directly addresses her emotional state. He notices she is crying, indicating her profound unhappiness.
"Why don’t you eat?" He further notices her physical state - her lack of appetite, which is often a sign of deep distress or depression. Eating less is also a sign of mourning.
"Why is your heart grieved?" This question delves deeper into the root cause of her suffering. He recognizes that her sadness goes beyond surface-level unhappiness and is seated in her heart.
"Am I not better to you than ten sons?" This is the most significant part of the verse. Here, Elkanah attempts to console Hannah by asserting his love and value as her husband. He implies that his affection and companionship should be enough to compensate for her lack of children.
Meaning and Interpretation:
Elkanah's Love and Intention: Elkanah genuinely loves Hannah and wants to ease her pain. His question comes from a place of care and concern. He is trying to reassure her that she is valued and loved, regardless of her inability to bear children.
Societal Context: In ancient Israelite society, a woman's primary role was to bear children, particularly sons, to carry on the family name and inheritance. Barrenness was a source of shame and social stigma for women.
Misunderstanding Hannah's Pain: While Elkanah's intentions are good, his statement reflects a misunderstanding of the depth of Hannah's pain. He may not fully grasp the societal pressure and personal longing she experiences due to her barrenness. For Hannah, having children was not just about having offspring, but about fulfilling her role in society, having someone to ensure that she would be secure in her old age, and having the joy of motherhood.
Limitations of Human Comfort: The verse illustrates the limitations of even well-intentioned human comfort. While Elkanah's love is valuable, it cannot completely alleviate Hannah's deep-seated desire for a child. Hannah needed more than reassurances; she needed divine intervention.
Hannah's Determination: Despite Elkanah's attempt to comfort her, Hannah ultimately turns to God in prayer. This shows her deep faith and her belief that God can answer her prayers and fulfill her desires.
In essence, this verse highlights the complexities of marriage, the societal pressures surrounding childbearing, the limits of human comfort, and the power of faith and prayer in overcoming personal struggles. Elkanah's love is genuine, but Hannah's longing for a child is profound, and she ultimately seeks solace and fulfillment from God.
1 samuel 1:8 - Elkanah her husband said to her, “Hannah, why do you weep? Why don’t you eat? Why is your heart grieved? Am I not better to you than ten sons?”
What does "1 samuel 1:8" mean?
This verse from 1 Samuel 1:8 is a poignant moment where Elkanah tries to comfort his wife, Hannah, who is deeply distressed because she is barren and cannot have children. Let's break it down:
"Elkanah her husband said to her, “Hannah, why do you weep?" Elkanah observes Hannah's sorrow and directly addresses her emotional state. He notices she is crying, indicating her profound unhappiness.
"Why don’t you eat?" He further notices her physical state - her lack of appetite, which is often a sign of deep distress or depression. Eating less is also a sign of mourning.
"Why is your heart grieved?" This question delves deeper into the root cause of her suffering. He recognizes that her sadness goes beyond surface-level unhappiness and is seated in her heart.
"Am I not better to you than ten sons?" This is the most significant part of the verse. Here, Elkanah attempts to console Hannah by asserting his love and value as her husband. He implies that his affection and companionship should be enough to compensate for her lack of children.
Meaning and Interpretation:
Elkanah's Love and Intention: Elkanah genuinely loves Hannah and wants to ease her pain. His question comes from a place of care and concern. He is trying to reassure her that she is valued and loved, regardless of her inability to bear children.
Societal Context: In ancient Israelite society, a woman's primary role was to bear children, particularly sons, to carry on the family name and inheritance. Barrenness was a source of shame and social stigma for women.
Misunderstanding Hannah's Pain: While Elkanah's intentions are good, his statement reflects a misunderstanding of the depth of Hannah's pain. He may not fully grasp the societal pressure and personal longing she experiences due to her barrenness. For Hannah, having children was not just about having offspring, but about fulfilling her role in society, having someone to ensure that she would be secure in her old age, and having the joy of motherhood.
Limitations of Human Comfort: The verse illustrates the limitations of even well-intentioned human comfort. While Elkanah's love is valuable, it cannot completely alleviate Hannah's deep-seated desire for a child. Hannah needed more than reassurances; she needed divine intervention.
Hannah's Determination: Despite Elkanah's attempt to comfort her, Hannah ultimately turns to God in prayer. This shows her deep faith and her belief that God can answer her prayers and fulfill her desires.
In essence, this verse highlights the complexities of marriage, the societal pressures surrounding childbearing, the limits of human comfort, and the power of faith and prayer in overcoming personal struggles. Elkanah's love is genuine, but Hannah's longing for a child is profound, and she ultimately seeks solace and fulfillment from God.