1 john 5:7 - For there are three who testify:
Select Bible Verse
Filter Categories
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
R
S
T
U
V
W
What does "1 john 5:7" mean?
The verse "For there are three who testify" in 1 John 5:7 (specifically when followed by the "Johannine Comma") is one of the most debated verses in the New Testament. Its meaning and authenticity are highly contested.
The Two Main Views:
Without the Johannine Comma (the more accepted view today): In most modern Bibles, 1 John 5:7 reads simply, "For there are three that testify." In this case, it refers to the three witnesses mentioned in verse 8: the Spirit, the water, and the blood. These are interpreted as:
The Spirit: The Holy Spirit, who bears witness to the truth of Jesus's identity and mission.
The Water: Likely referring to Jesus's baptism, which publicly declared him as the Messiah.
The Blood: Referring to Jesus's atoning death on the cross, which provided redemption for humanity.
The overall meaning is that these three elements work together to testify that Jesus is the Son of God and the source of eternal life. They represent key aspects of Jesus's life, ministry, and saving work.
With the Johannine Comma (disputed and less accepted): This longer version, found in the King James Version and some older translations, adds: "For there are three that bear record in heaven, the Father, the Word, and the Holy Ghost: and these three are one. And there are three that bear witness in earth, the spirit, and the water, and the blood: and these three agree in one."
In this case, the verse is interpreted as directly referencing the Trinity:
The Father: God the Father.
The Word: Jesus Christ, the eternal Word of God.
The Holy Ghost: The Holy Spirit.
The phrase "these three are one" is seen as a clear statement of the unity and equality of the three persons of the Trinity. The second set of three refers to the same witnesses as above (spirit, water, and blood).
Why the Controversy?
The longer version (with the Johannine Comma) is almost certainly a later addition to the original text. Here's why:
Lack of Early Manuscript Evidence: The Johannine Comma is absent from virtually all early Greek manuscripts of 1 John. It appears only in a few late medieval manuscripts, primarily from the 15th century onward.
Textual Criticism: Textual scholars analyze the manuscript evidence and conclude that the longer reading is a corruption that crept into the text over time. It likely originated as a marginal note explaining the Trinity, which was later inserted into the text.
Inconsistent Style: The language and style of the Johannine Comma are somewhat different from the rest of 1 John, further suggesting that it is not original.
Theological Motivation: Some believe that the Comma was added to provide stronger scriptural support for the doctrine of the Trinity, which was being developed and debated in the early church.
In Summary:
The most accurate understanding of 1 John 5:7, based on the best available evidence, is the shorter version: "For there are three that testify." These three witnesses (the Spirit, the water, and the blood) point to the truth that Jesus is the Son of God and the source of eternal life. The longer version (with the Johannine Comma) is a later addition and not considered part of the original text. While it aligns with Trinitarian theology, its inclusion in the text is not supported by robust historical evidence.
1 john 5:7 - For there are three who testify:
What does "1 john 5:7" mean?
The verse "For there are three who testify" in 1 John 5:7 (specifically when followed by the "Johannine Comma") is one of the most debated verses in the New Testament. Its meaning and authenticity are highly contested.
The Two Main Views:
Without the Johannine Comma (the more accepted view today): In most modern Bibles, 1 John 5:7 reads simply, "For there are three that testify." In this case, it refers to the three witnesses mentioned in verse 8: the Spirit, the water, and the blood. These are interpreted as:
The Spirit: The Holy Spirit, who bears witness to the truth of Jesus's identity and mission.
The Water: Likely referring to Jesus's baptism, which publicly declared him as the Messiah.
The Blood: Referring to Jesus's atoning death on the cross, which provided redemption for humanity.
The overall meaning is that these three elements work together to testify that Jesus is the Son of God and the source of eternal life. They represent key aspects of Jesus's life, ministry, and saving work.
With the Johannine Comma (disputed and less accepted): This longer version, found in the King James Version and some older translations, adds: "For there are three that bear record in heaven, the Father, the Word, and the Holy Ghost: and these three are one. And there are three that bear witness in earth, the spirit, and the water, and the blood: and these three agree in one."
In this case, the verse is interpreted as directly referencing the Trinity:
The Father: God the Father.
The Word: Jesus Christ, the eternal Word of God.
The Holy Ghost: The Holy Spirit.
The phrase "these three are one" is seen as a clear statement of the unity and equality of the three persons of the Trinity. The second set of three refers to the same witnesses as above (spirit, water, and blood).
Why the Controversy?
The longer version (with the Johannine Comma) is almost certainly a later addition to the original text. Here's why:
Lack of Early Manuscript Evidence: The Johannine Comma is absent from virtually all early Greek manuscripts of 1 John. It appears only in a few late medieval manuscripts, primarily from the 15th century onward.
Textual Criticism: Textual scholars analyze the manuscript evidence and conclude that the longer reading is a corruption that crept into the text over time. It likely originated as a marginal note explaining the Trinity, which was later inserted into the text.
Inconsistent Style: The language and style of the Johannine Comma are somewhat different from the rest of 1 John, further suggesting that it is not original.
Theological Motivation: Some believe that the Comma was added to provide stronger scriptural support for the doctrine of the Trinity, which was being developed and debated in the early church.
In Summary:
The most accurate understanding of 1 John 5:7, based on the best available evidence, is the shorter version: "For there are three that testify." These three witnesses (the Spirit, the water, and the blood) point to the truth that Jesus is the Son of God and the source of eternal life. The longer version (with the Johannine Comma) is a later addition and not considered part of the original text. While it aligns with Trinitarian theology, its inclusion in the text is not supported by robust historical evidence.